The facts are these: First, Jewry is absolutely a race and not a religious association.
In Defense of Fat Acceptance. Following many of the same arguments common of the writings of Hillel Schwartz and other overweight defense activists Worley seeks to dispel and shatter many of the stereotypes often placed upon the overweight. In her essay Worley uses the idea of planets to show the difference between the real world and the atmosphere she experienced at the NAAFA convention.
According to the author overweight individuals cannot find clothes or swimsuits that look good or even fit. To Worley fat persons are always supposed to be embarrassed about their size and should strive to fix it.
When she attends the convention she finds a planet where swimsuits do fit and look great. In this planet fat is beautiful.
In the end Mary argues that fat persons have learned how to enjoy their bodies and create a balance with them instead of disdaining their bodies as skinny persons do. Mary Ray Worley is no different than any other disgruntled fat person. She is not upset about the option of losing weight.
How could she be? Any doctor, scientist, medical professional or athletic trainer will tell their peers that 2 pounds of weight loss per week is not dangerous for the human body. Worley is not angry about becoming healthy; she is angry with being told to lose weight—to become healthy.
Worley levels her anger against doctors in her rant. Regardless of the ailment you are seeking treatment for, if you are fat, your doctor may put you on a diet before she treats your cough, and attribute whatever complaint you have to your weight.
Indeed, Mary is guilty of the same stereotyping that she condemns society for. Fighting fire with fire the author stereotypes doctors, everyone who is not fat and diet programs. This does nothing to help her cause.
Worley does not pose any solutions or alternatives at all, besides accommodating the unhealthy. Worley is correct on one count: It is not hard to understand why. Such a medical complication like excess body fat is not so different from other behaviors that can be harmful to the body.
Should a pot smoker come in complaining of the same problems the doctor will most likely attribute the lung issues to the pot smoking as pot smoke is more harmful to the lungs than tobacco smoke.
If a man uses smokeless tobacco and complains about gum problems to his dentist it should come as no shock to him if his dentist informs him that the tobacco is the root of his gum disease. Why should a diagnosis that blames excess fat for a medical condition be any different?
An addiction to food and the endorphins that it releases in the brain is no different from an addiction to tobacco, marijuana or alcohol. All of these addictions can lead to severe medical problems: Some surgeons have a difficult time performing surgery of any kind on fat or obese people simply because there are so many layers of fat one must cut through before one can reach organs, muscles, arteries, etcetera.
Despite all of this the smoker does not wish to be told to quit smoking, the chewer—if that term exists—does not wish to be told to quit chewing, the druggie does not wish to be told to quit doing drugs, the alcoholic does not wish to be told to quit drinking, and the fatty does not wish to be told to curtail the food intake.
Perhaps Mary should start listening to her doctor. The listings of the ingredients, the percentages and measurements of those components and the calories per serving are listed on foods for the same reason that Surgeon General Warnings exist on tobacco products and warnings advocating for moderation and safety exist on bottles of alcohol.The Online Writing Lab (OWL) at Purdue University houses writing resources and instructional material, and we provide these as a free service of the Writing Lab at Purdue.
Fat and Happy Hillel Schwartz Critique Essay Sample. In Fat and Happy, Hillel Schwartz is examining the arguments over obesity and the effectiveness of its treatments.
Paul Kingsnorth is a writer and poet living in Cumbria, England. He is the author of several books, including the poetry collection Kidland and his fictional debut The Wake, winner of the Gordon Burn Prize and the Bookseller Book of the Year Award.
Kingsnorth is the cofounder and director of the Dark Mountain Project, a network of writers, artists, and thinkers. Jan 28, · The story of how basic questions about what to eat got so complicated reveals a great deal about the institutional imperatives of the food industry, nutritional science and journalism.
Free Essay: As obesity escalates towards becoming an epidemic in modern day America, pressures to stay fit have become overwhelming from media and doctors.
In the article “Fat and Happy?”, Hillel Schwartz questions why society views fat people as pathetic and unacceptable. He argues that if it were not for “fellow citizens” () mocking and scorning them for being fat, they would be perfectly content with themselves.